What Failed State?
Pakistan’s state machinery is working fine.
Islamabad has implemented one of the most severe blockages of public movement in the country’s history. [Update: It didn't work too well in Lahore.] Remember, this is a country of 165 million.
Major national highways and city roads are off limits. Shipping containers have been laid out on the roads by the Zardari-dominated Gilani government to prevent a sizable assembly of Long March protesters. [Good luck to exporters with shipping deadlines to meet!]
The Pakistan Army is deployed in Islamabad in full force to prevent public assembly. [It's unclear as to whether they are just following orders to let Zardari self-destruct completely or whether Army Chief Kayani is in on the draconian measures against Pakistan's citizenry.]
The provincial police services and national intelligence agencies – including, some lawyers movement activists claim, plainclothes ISI officers — have detained dozens of major civil society and political leaders. They have also arrested hundreds of lawyers and party activists.
The most watched news channel is blocked in much of the country. Even dorm residents at Islamabad’s Quaid-e Azam University were booted out of their housing facilities — many or most with no place to go. SMS service has been blocked in Islamabad. This could extend to the rest of the country.
The Zardari-dominated government (I write Zardari-dominated because the government is technically that of Gilani, the dodo premier who wears no clothes) has demonstrated very well that it is able to develop a comprehensive strategy to combat a threat to its creeping hegemony and use a wide range of elements of the state apparatus to execute it.
Granted, it is facing a non-violent opposition. It is easy to suppress the peaceful and unarmed. Fighting cannibalistic terrorists is another matter. Rehman Malik, now de-facto interior minister, ran away to Zardari House in Islamabad after Benazir Bhutto was assassinated, despite being in charge of her security.
Proclamations of the demise of the Pakistani state are always premature as long as the state is able to function at will. The will, tragically, is generally demonstrated for the sake of self-preservation or aggrandizement.
The state performs well when it wants to, when the major elements of the state work in concert with one another. As with today, it is for the wrong reasons.
But in losing legitimacy and earning the hatred of the people, authoritarians win the battle and lose the war. It is all downhill for Zardari from here. In his fake psychiatric report, Zardari claimed to be suffering from amnesia. Apparently he forgot what happened to Musharraf in 2007-8.
Update: 4:45AM (New York) – Zardari just lost the battle of Lahore and the entire war. I think the game will be over soon. Bilawal — take out the sleeping bag. Papa’s coming for a visit.







Recent Comments