Apr 2, 2008
Words of the Day: Consensus and Reconciliation
The national reconciliation and consensus bus in Pakistan continues to move forward at a steady pace. Today, the country witnessed two, potentially historic, meetings: the first between senior military and civilian officials, and the second between the People’s Party (PPP) and long-time rival Muttahida Qaumi Movement (MQM).
KAYANI BRIEFS CABINET AND POLITICIANS ON FATA
This morning, Army Chief of Staff Gen. Ashfaq Kayani gave a briefing on the Federally-Administered Tribal Areas (FATA) to senior Pakistani officials and politicians at the prime minister’s house.
Attending the session were not only Prime Minister Yousaf Raza Gillani and cabinet members Foreign Minister Shah Mehmood Qureshi and Defense Minister Mukhtar Ahmed, but also leaders of the coalition government parties not currently in the cabinet or parliament, including Asif Zardari, Nawaz and Shahbaz Sharif, Asfandyar Wali, and Fazlur Rahman. It seems as if Pervez Musharraf was not present, but he did meet with Kayani separately.
Fazlur Rahman, speaking to GEO News, said the briefing was followed by a free and frank discussion among the participants. He said there was a consensus that negotiations were an important part of the solution to the challenges in FATA. Audio-less video of the briefing session showed a normally demure Kayani speaking in a fairly engaged fashion.
The meeting, which seems to have been initiated by Gen. Kayani, indicates that both the civil and military leadership would like to develop a uniform security policy. Also, it suggests that political and security decisions will be the product of civil-military dialog, with the elected leadership holding precedence. Gen. Kayani has been keen to adhere to constitutional propriety. Senior Pakistani journalist Nusrat Javed said the meeting also demonstrates that the Musharraf-established National Security Council is effectively done with.
It has taken almost two months to form a governing coalition, select and elect a prime minister, and compose a cabinet. In and before this period, U.S. military officials have made almost weekly visits to Gen. Kayani, hoping to secure commitments from him that would withstand a potentially obdurate civilian government. But such an arrangement would be untenable as it would pit the army chief of staff against the civilian leadership.
Gen. Kayani’s well-timed briefing can, hopefully, empower the civilian leadership to engage one another, the public, and foreign governments in an informed discussion on how to resolve the crisis in FATA.
PPP-MQM RECONCILIATION
After the morning meeting, People’s Party Co-Chairman Asif Zardari made his way to Karachi, where he met with senior leaders of the Muttahida Qaumi Movement (MQM). Zardari said a prayer at the grave of the brother of MQM chief Altaf Hussain and then went to Nine-Zero, the MQM’s headquarters, in Liaquatabad.
Details of the talks have been sparse, but the PPP and MQM leaders presumably discussed a broad rapprochement and, more specifically, the modalities of the MQM joining the federal and Sindh governments.
Relations between the two parties in the past two decades have been bloody. Political and ethnic violence has plagued Karachi, once among Pakistan’s better cities. Reconciliation between the PPP and MQM could help improve the quality of life in Karachi, an overcrowded metropolis.
However, coalition government members PML-N and the ANP have expressed strong reservations against bringing the MQM into the federal cabinet. Given that Zardari has been careful not to alienate his coalition partners, it’s likely that they endorsed his meeting with the MQM.
Once the talks ended, Zardari and Altaf (via telephone from London) spoke at a press conference/rally. Significantly, both admitted to having wronged one another in the past, exchanged apologies and pleas for forgiveness. In a symbolic display, senior MQM leader Farooq Sattar gave an offering of a Sindhi cap and shawl to Zardari, who then placed he Sindhi cap he was wearing on Sattar’s head.
Zardari also spoke of the costs of PPP-MQM conflict, noting “lost opportunities” in the past. He said his generation “lost a long period of time,” but that “nations can rise from ashes.” He added: “If it could be done in Nagasaki, it can be done here.”
The PPP co-chairman said that unnamed “enemies…know how to tear the country apart, but we know how to build it.” This day, he said, would be a watershed moment in Pakistan’s history; it would be noted as the day that Pakistan’s largest party came to Karachi to ask for forgiveness.
He ended his speech with an eclectic: “Long live Bhutto. Long live Altaf. Long live Pakistan.”








What is exhilirating about the new elected leadership of Pakistan is the WISDOM AND MATURITY they have shown in dealing with issues and also dealing with themselves. This stands in sharp contrast to the HOLIER than attitude of the Military dicator who thought he is the embodiment of WISdOM.
People of Pakistan have to show only patience and tolerance so that this ELECTED LEADERSHIP is allowed to do WHAT MAY BE CORRECT OR EVEN INCORRECT descisions. Because you can change them if they falter.
I have to say, Zardari (of all people) is really giving my cynicism a run for its money.
How long do you think this can hold before things get acrimonious within the PDA? Is there a foreseeable stumbling block?
Also, what is your opinion on the sincerity of the national reconciliation that is currently taking place(so far Balochistan-PPP, and MQM-PPP)?
Alliances don’t last long in Pakistan. I think that’s why Pakistan is abound with cynicism.
Zardari has tempered my skepticism. He has been saying and doing all the right things. It’s both eerie and encouraging.
As far as acrimony within the PDA, I think the pundits have been talking about this for months. Some see the MQM-PPP reconciliation as a means to check the PML-N, pushing it to the periphery (or even outside) of the coalition. But I don’t anticipate that occurring. The optimist in me senses some substantive change within Zardari and that he’s learning to listen to the right people. I also don’t see any indication that his dealings with the MQM have been done against the PML-N’s will.
I would say reconciliation w/ the MQM would have higher odds of success if its goals were limited and did not supplant the PPP’s partnership with the PML-N. I think the Balochistan issue is a lot more complicated. Baloch leaders seem to have reacted coolly to Zardari’s apologies. They obviously want more than words and so that will take more time and patience.
Thank you for your reply. I agree, and hope that Zardari really has changed to the extent that his actions suggest.
You mentioned that hes learning to listen to the right people. Do you have any particular individuals in mind?
None that I can say safely in public. But I think, generally speaking, that he’s moved away from his goonda friends.